TODAY IN THE ORCHARD
Newtown Scott Farm (above) and Peck Pleasant from the USDA watercolors in Bussey (below)
Today I spent time with the apple that is thought to be Newtown Pippin at Scott Farm in Vermont. Recently, a few people have doubted the identity. I closely examined a dozen apples of “Newtown Scott Farm” (NSF), and I concluded that the “Newtown Scott Farm” NSF is not Newtown Pippin (NP). Although there are definite similarities between NSF and NP, and it’s not difficult to see how the two could be confused with one another, there are many obvious differences between the two.
Newtown Scott Farm may be the old Rhode Island cultivar, Peck Pleasant (PP). The descriptions of PP match NSF almost perfectly with no deal-breaking differences (Bussey, Vol V p119.) The USDA watercolor (Bussey, Vol V p217) is an exact match.
Scionwood for “Green Newtown Pippin,” “Yellow Newtown Pippin” and “Peck Pleasant” were all obtainable for decades from Tower Hill Botanic Garden (THBG) in MA. There is a chance that if the scionwood came from THBG, it could have been mixed up. In the THBG orchard (now gone and replaced) from which the scionwood would have come, Peck Pleasant was tree #108 and Green Newtown was #110, making them, presumably, just one cultivar apart in the row. So it’s possible that Newtown Scionwood was ordered and Peck Pleasant was sent by mistake or that Scott Farm mixed up the labeling when the trees were grafted or over the ensuing years. If NSF has not been DNA profiled, it should be DNA profiled.